Comma In Quotes After Question Mark
Also, the stronger punctuation mark wins.
Comma in quotes after question mark. This rule makes good sense; Colons and semicolons are placed outside quotations, while question marks and exclamation marks follow the logic of the sentence. Publication manual), as do several other major style guides (such as ap, chicago, and mla).the table below elaborates, with examples for each punctuation mark.
If a question is within the quoted material, a question mark should be placed inside the quotation marks. Semicolons, colons, and dashes always go outside the closing quotation mark. Usually, they appear as a separate paragraph (or series of paragraphs) with a different font, a change in the line spacing, or a wider margin.
Do you agree with the saying, all's fair in love. Colons and semicolons should be outside the quotation marks. This situation wouldn't arise under chicago rules because chicago follows general u.s.
Dialogue tag after a quote. If a question is within the quoted material, a question mark should be placed inside the quotation marks. (the comma would go outside the quotation marks for bre.) the comma is still necessary in this case because the question mark is not replacing it.
Did he just ask, ???how are you???? wrong: It???s worth hanging around [writers.se] as these sorts of questions come up there occasionally. It distinguishes a quoted question from a quotation embedded in a question.
She asked, will you still be my friend? the question will you still be my friend? The chicago manual of style editors make a similar recommendation for attributions, but take a new stance on titles in their newest edition (16th edition, section 6.119): When the material being quoted contains a quotation within a.
(correct) the dialogue tag (grumbled dan) comes after the quotation, so a comma is required after the word ???this.??? As long as the order isn???t significant, placing the virginia wolfe title at the end would avoid the comma after the question mark and the question mark would end the sentence. The placement of question marks with quotation marks follows logic.
This really is a purely stylistic question. The piano mover answered betsy, but no one could understand his words. 92 of the 6th ed.
Question marks and exclamation points require you to think about the sentence a little to determine where they go. She asked, will you still be my friend? the question will you still be my friend? Keep the comma after a title.
Periods and commas always go inside the closing quotation mark (in american english). Block quotes are long quotes that are separated from the surrounding text. There is a punctuation mark that combines the question mark and exclamation point.
Instead, the attributive tag should come immediately after the closing quotation marks.consider the example below: Time to look at one more part of betsy???s encounter with the falling piano. For example, take a look at the following sentence:
In the uk, the tendency is to place them outside. Therefore, no period after war is used. The greatest confusion arises when exclamation points and other punctuation marks appear at the end of a sentence.
A comma or period that follows a closing double quotation mark hangs off by itself and creates a gap in the line of text (since the space over the comma or period combines with the following word space). *place other punctuation inside quotation marks when that punctuation is part of what is being quoted, such as a quoted question. Dale, you???re right, the italicized title gets lost in the italicized example.
Should i place the comma in the quotes, or outside the quotes? Whether a question mark or an exclamation point should appear inside or outside the quotation marks depends on the meaning. Style in placing commas inside quotation marks instead of outside them.
With a fragmentary quotation (not a complete sentence), do not use a comma before the quote nor a capital to start the quote. If two of your characters are having a conversation, the dialogue (and proper punctuation placement) might go something like this: This page has examples showing the different conventions for placing punctuation inside or outside quotation marks.
Further to the other answers, if a sentence is a question, and that sentence includes a quoted question, put one question mark inside the quotation marks. In any case, block quotes don???t need quotation marks to set them off from the remaining text, even though they are direct quotes. Personally (and this is just an opinion, so kinda asking for this to be put on hold), i would italicise the title, and probably leave out both the commas and the quotation marks, but if i were writing within any kind of ???house style??? this is subject.
In cases when a question mark is used, there is no need to use a comma as well; These rules have no exceptions. They recommend keeping the comma when a title ends with a question mark or exclamation point, as in the example above from the grammar girl podcast.
Therefore, according to chicago, which. Quotation marks and fragmentary quotes. ???i can???t believe you???re actually making me do this,??? grumbled dan.
As you might guess from our name, apa style uses american style punctuation (see p. If you quote a question, put the question mark inside the quotation marks. Yes, the comma goes inside the quotation marks and after the question mark because the question mark is part of the periodical???s title.
Quotation marks would be incorrect because the title is a long work. It is called the interrobang, and it looks like this: Read on to find out why and lessen the confusion
The placement of question marks with quotation marks follows logic. Do you agree with the saying, all's fair in love. Don't use two question marks.
Insert a comma after the clause between the first and second part of a split quote. The comma is the mark most frequently used to introduce quoted material. Traditionally, i would place it in the quotes, but i wasn't too sure if i could place a comma right after a question mark like that.
The question mark should always appear at the end of the question???whether that's the end of the sentence or not. ??? yet, for reasons already explained, it is hardly needed. Does punctuation go inside quotation marks?
Is part of the quotation. British publishers tend to put the comma or period after the quotation mark. Did she say, ???may i go???? pop quiz.
Instead, use a period, as in the following example: The answer is both yes and no! No one is here yet, she complained, and it's almost midnight. leave out the comma when the first part of a quote ends with an exclamation point or question mark.
The comma or period at the end of the quotation should always be placed inside the quotation marks. In the us, periods and commas are placed inside quotation marks. Is part of the quotation.
